Introduction
…And Justice for All isn’t just an album — it’s a monument.
Cold, complex, technical, furious, politically charged, bone-dry, and famously missing one of the most important elements in metal: the bass guitar.
Released on September 7, 1988, it was Metallica’s first studio album after the tragic death of Cliff Burton. It introduced new bassist Jason Newsted, marking the beginning of a new, darker era for the band.
The album is:
– massive in scope
– aggressive in attitude
– progressive in structure
– brutally unfiltered in production
– politically explosive
This is Metallica at their most intellectually violent.
It’s the band grieving, evolving, and pushing themselves to the absolute limit.
What Is “…And Justice for All”? (Album Overview)
Musical Style
– progressive thrash metal
– long, complex arrangements
– intricate riffs
– aggressive tempo changes
– highly technical drumming
– famously thin, bass-light production
This album is not “catchy” in the traditional sense.
It’s architectural metal — a labyrinth built out of riffs.
Themes
It is Metallica’s most political album ever, focusing on:
– corruption
– war
– injustice
– censorship
– government abuse
– mental collapse
– manipulation
– loss
– institutional cruelty
The lyrics are darker, more serious, and more mature than anything before it.
Why the Episode Matters
Because …Justice is:
– the album that proved Metallica could survive Cliff’s death
– the album that elevated them to stadium-level seriousness
– the album that earned them their FIRST Grammy
– the album containing “One,” one of the greatest metal songs ever written
It’s the turning point between underground thrash and global metal supremacy.
History of Creation
The Band After Cliff Burton’s Death
Cliff Burton died on September 27, 1986 in a bus accident during the Master of Puppets tour.
Metallica responded by:
– pushing forward with Jason Newsted
– burying themselves in work
– writing relentlessly
– refusing to slow down or emotionally process the trauma
The result was an album that feels cold, bitter, exhausted, and obsessive — because that’s exactly what the band was.
Writing the Album
Hetfield and Ulrich locked themselves in a room and wrote:
– longer songs
– more intricate structures
– more tempo changes
– more riffs per song than most albums have in total
Some songs contain:
– 20+ riffs
– movements instead of verses
– odd time signatures
– extended instrumental passages
They wanted complexity and aggression, not accessibility.
Recording Sessions
Recorded at One on One Recording Studios in Los Angeles.
The Process Was Brutal
– Lars demanded perfect drum edits
– James wanted ultra-dry guitars
– bass was repeatedly cut down in the mix
– songs were extremely difficult to track
– the sessions were tense, rigid, exhausting
Jason Newsted, the new bassist, was hazed heavily.
Part of that hazing ended up in the mix:
the bass was dialed down to near zero.
This decision has followed Metallica for decades.
The Infamous Bass Controversy
Why Is the Bass So Quiet?
Two reasons:
- Hazing Jason Newsted
James & Lars have admitted that Jason was treated unfairly — the mix reflected the emotional dynamic. - Production Philosophy
The band wanted the guitars and drums to sound massive and tight.
The bass was tucked under the guitars until it became invisible.
Fans Still Debating It 35 Years Later
It’s the most controversial production choice in metal history.
The album is iconic because of it — and in spite of it.
The Album Cover — Meaning & Symbolism
The artwork is one of the most iconic metal covers ever made.
Artist
Pushead (Brian Schroeder), Metallica’s longtime artist.
Visual Elements
– Lady Justice (Justitia)
– blindfold cracked
– scales broken
– bound by ropes
– collapsing
– money stuffed in her scales
– entire statue crumbling
Meaning
The cover represents:
– corruption of law
– bribery
– political hypocrisy
– systems collapsing under their own lies
The album title “…And Justice for All” is intentionally sarcastic.
There is no justice in these songs — only decay.
Color Palette
The sickly green-gray tone symbolizes:
– decay
– institutional rot
– lifelessness
– coldness
The cover perfectly matches the album’s sound.
Tracklist (Original 1988)
- Blackened
- …And Justice for All
- Eye of the Beholder
- One
- The Shortest Straw
- Harvester of Sorrow
- The Frayed Ends of Sanity
- To Live Is to Die
- Dyers Eve
Blackened
A nuclear sunrise in riff form.
“Blackened” is an apocalyptic environmental warning — the world poisoned, the sky darkened, humanity choking in the smoke of its own destruction. It’s early Metallica’s most politically direct opener, written as an environmental protest long before “climate change” was common vocabulary.
Musically, it’s a maze of tempo changes, reversed intro tape tricks, and relentless thrash aggression. It immediately announces that this album will be more complex and more chaotic than anything before it.
…And Justice for All
The title track and the album’s thesis statement.
This song is an 8-minute indictment of corrupt legal and political systems — justice sold to the highest bidder, truth manipulated, fairness dead. The lyrics are bitter, sarcastic, and furious.
Musically, it’s built on shifting time signatures and multiple movements — closer to metal “progressive rock” than traditional thrash.
This track might be the coldest, driest production Metallica ever recorded, which reinforces the theme: justice has no warmth.
Eye of the Beholder
A song about censorship, control, and surveillance masquerading as “freedom.”
The lyrics attack institutions and governments that preach freedom while restricting speech, identity, thought, and individuality. One of Hetfield’s recurring themes is here: freedom is only freedom when everyone has it.
Musically, this track is full of rhythmic dissonance — awkward shifts, unexpected beats, and rigid patterns that reflect the theme of being boxed in.
One
Metallica’s first mainstream breakthrough — a chilling, cinematic masterpiece based on Johnny Got His Gun.
It tells the story of a soldier who survives a battlefield explosion but loses all limbs, sight, speech, and hearing — trapped in his own mind, begging for death.
The first half is quiet and mournful; the second half erupts into mechanized thrash warfare, one of the greatest transitions in metal history.
The machine-gun guitar/drum sync at the end became iconic — a moment that defined Metallica’s legacy.
The Shortest Straw
A paranoia-driven political attack.
“The Shortest Straw” is about blacklisting — punishing people for their beliefs, associations, or identities, especially during the McCarthy era. Hetfield spits each line like accusation and protest.
Musically, this is thrash at its sharpest: tight palm-muting, rapid-fire riffs, aggressive phrasing.
The tension in the song mirrors the fear of being targeted.
Harvester of Sorrow
One of the darkest lyrical pieces Metallica ever wrote.
It tells the story of a man who snaps under trauma, depression, and internal chaos — spiraling into violence against the people he should protect.
The song is slow, heavy, suffocating — a psychological collapse in slow motion.
This track shows Metallica’s ability to evoke horror without needing speed.
The Frayed Ends of Sanity
This is anxiety, paranoia, and mental unraveling turned into an 8-minute labyrinth.
The intro quotes The Wizard of Oz scarecrow chant (“O-EE-OH”) twisted into something demonic.
The lyrics describe someone losing touch with reality — fear eating them alive.
Musically, it might be the most mathematically complex track on the album. Constant riff transitions, strange rhythmic phrasing, and relentless tension make it one of Metallica’s most underrated masterpieces.
To Live Is to Die
Metallica’s tribute to Cliff Burton — the emotional center of the album.
The song is mostly instrumental, built around riffs and ideas that Cliff had written before his death. The spoken passage (“When a man lies…”) is one of the most iconic moments in Metallica’s catalog.
It’s mournful, poetic, and full of grief.
This is the moment where the band lets themselves feel the loss they spent two years avoiding.
Dyers Eve
The fastest, angriest, most personal song Metallica had written up to this point.
The lyrics are a direct attack on James Hetfield’s parents and his traumatic upbringing, especially the emotional suppression he experienced in a strict Christian Science household.
It’s pure rage — the sound of someone confronting childhood wounds that never healed.
Musically, it’s a thrash hurricane: relentless double bass, high-speed riffing, and no break for air.
This is the album ending with emotional detonation.
James Hetfield — Guitars
Main Rhythm Guitars
James tracked rhythm guitars using:
– ESP MX220 “Eet Fuk” Explorer (his main weapon during this era)
– Gibson Explorer (backup)
– Jackson King V (occasionally used for overdubs)
These guitars are loaded with EMG 81 active pickups — ultra-tight and perfect for dry, surgical metal.
Why the Tone Is So Tight
Hetfield’s right-hand technique is basically its own instrument.
This album is palm-muted thrash machine-gun precision at god-tier level.
He double-tracked everything perfectly, sometimes more than twice.
These layers smothered the bass frequencies — one reason Jason disappeared.
James’ Amplifiers
This is where the tone gets famous.
Main Amp Setup
– Mesa/Boogie Mark II C+ modified
– Mesa/Boogie Mark III
– Marshall JCM800 blended for bite
The Mark IIC+ is the heart of the sound — a razor-sharp, mid-forward, ultra-dry thrash tone.
No reverb. No warmth. No room.
The guitars are DEAD DRY.
No space.
No air.
Just pure riff architecture.
This dryness emphasizes every riff detail — but kills low-end.
Kirk Hammett — Leads & Effects
Guitars
– Jackson Randy Rhoads (main)
– ESP M-II early prototypes
– Gibson Flying V occasionally
Pedals
– Ibanez Tube Screamer
– Cry Baby Wah
– Rack chorus/delay (very subtle compared to later albums)
Kirk’s tone on this album is sharper and more mid-forward than on Master of Puppets.
His leads slice through the mix because the rhythm guitars occupy EVERYTHING BELOW them.
Jason Newsted — Bass (Or What’s Left Of It)
Here’s the infamous part.
Jason’s Actual Gear
He recorded using:
– Sadowsky 4-string bass
– Alembic-style preamp tone
– Gallien-Krueger amps
– Direct input tracks
His tone was aggressive, punchy, and CLEAR — he played tightly with James.
BUT… the bass was nearly erased.
Why?
- Hazing — Jason was the new guy after Cliff’s death
- James’ massive guitar tracks buried the low end
- Lars demanded the bass mimic the guitars exactly
- When the engineer raised the bass, Lars said:
“Turn it down until you can’t hear it. Then lower it another 5 dB.”
The result:
a metal album with almost no bass.
Jason’s Quote
“It was like being punched in the gut. I played my ass off, and it got buried.”
35 years later, fans STILL remix the album just to hear him.
Lars Ulrich — Drums
Drum Kit
– Tama Artstar
– Deep power toms
– 14×6.5 snare
– Paiste cymbals
The Drum Tone
This is one of the driest drum mixes ever recorded in mainstream metal.
– No reverb
– No room mics
– No ambience
– Snare: tight, papery crack
– Kicks: clicky, almost typewriter-like
– Toms: gated and clean
The drums were edited heavily, cut into perfect shapes.
This is why the album feels mechanical and rigid — exactly what they wanted.
Why the Album Sounds So Thin, Harsh, and Dry
Four main reasons:
1. Emotional Trauma
The band refused to admit they were grieving Cliff.
The music became cold, emotionless, rigid — it’s the sound of emotional shutdown.
2. Hetfield’s Guitar Wall
James tracked multiple layers of dry rhythm guitars.
They swallowed the frequency range the bass normally lives in.
3. Lars Controlled the Mix
Lars had very specific ideas:
– strong kick
– midrange-heavy snare
– guitars pushed to the front
– minimal bass
– dry as the desert
He basically dictated the production choices.
4. No One Challenged Them
Their producer, Flemming Rasmussen, wasn’t present for the final mixing stage.
James and Lars made the big decisions alone.
Recording Techniques
1. Hyper-precise editing
This is Metallica at their most structured — riffs are perfectly aligned, almost machine-like.
2. DI + Amp Blending
Guitars were blended with direct signals for clarity.
This increases dryness and reduces warmth.
3. Minimal overdubs on drums
Most drum power comes from tight editing, not layering.
4. Vocals mixed behind guitars
James’ voice is intentionally NOT dominant — unusual for Metallica.
Overall Sound Philosophy
…And Justice for All isn’t meant to sound “good” in the traditional sense.
It’s meant to sound:
– cold
– lifeless
– mechanical
– bitter
– rigid
– unforgiving
It mirrors the album’s themes of corruption, decay, and the breakdown of justice.
It’s the sound of law and society collapsing.
James Hetfield — Guitars
Main Rhythm Guitars
James tracked rhythm guitars using:
– ESP MX220 “Eet Fuk” Explorer (his main weapon during this era)
– Gibson Explorer (backup)
– Jackson King V (occasionally used for overdubs)
These guitars are loaded with EMG 81 active pickups — ultra-tight and perfect for dry, surgical metal.
Why the Tone Is So Tight
Hetfield’s right-hand technique is basically its own instrument.
This album is palm-muted thrash machine-gun precision at god-tier level.
He double-tracked everything perfectly, sometimes more than twice.
These layers smothered the bass frequencies — one reason Jason disappeared.
James’ Amplifiers
This is where the tone gets famous.
Main Amp Setup
– Mesa/Boogie Mark II C+ modified
– Mesa/Boogie Mark III
– Marshall JCM800 blended for bite
The Mark IIC+ is the heart of the sound — a razor-sharp, mid-forward, ultra-dry thrash tone.
No reverb. No warmth. No room.
The guitars are DEAD DRY.
No space.
No air.
Just pure riff architecture.
This dryness emphasizes every riff detail — but kills low-end.
Kirk Hammett — Leads & Effects
Guitars
– Jackson Randy Rhoads (main)
– ESP M-II early prototypes
– Gibson Flying V occasionally
Pedals
– Ibanez Tube Screamer
– Cry Baby Wah
– Rack chorus/delay (very subtle compared to later albums)
Kirk’s tone on this album is sharper and more mid-forward than on Master of Puppets.
His leads slice through the mix because the rhythm guitars occupy EVERYTHING BELOW them.
Jason Newsted — Bass (Or What’s Left Of It)
Here’s the infamous part.
Jason’s Actual Gear
He recorded using:
– Sadowsky 4-string bass
– Alembic-style preamp tone
– Gallien-Krueger amps
– Direct input tracks
His tone was aggressive, punchy, and CLEAR — he played tightly with James.
BUT… the bass was nearly erased.
Why?
- Hazing — Jason was the new guy after Cliff’s death
- James’ massive guitar tracks buried the low end
- Lars demanded the bass mimic the guitars exactly
- When the engineer raised the bass, Lars said:
“Turn it down until you can’t hear it. Then lower it another 5 dB.”
The result:
a metal album with almost no bass.
Jason’s Quote
“It was like being punched in the gut. I played my ass off, and it got buried.”
35 years later, fans STILL remix the album just to hear him.
Lars Ulrich — Drums
Drum Kit
– Tama Artstar
– Deep power toms
– 14×6.5 snare
– Paiste cymbals
The Drum Tone
This is one of the driest drum mixes ever recorded in mainstream metal.
– No reverb
– No room mics
– No ambience
– Snare: tight, papery crack
– Kicks: clicky, almost typewriter-like
– Toms: gated and clean
The drums were edited heavily, cut into perfect shapes.
This is why the album feels mechanical and rigid — exactly what they wanted.
Why the Album Sounds So Thin, Harsh, and Dry
Four main reasons:
1. Emotional Trauma
The band refused to admit they were grieving Cliff.
The music became cold, emotionless, rigid — it’s the sound of emotional shutdown.
2. Hetfield’s Guitar Wall
James tracked multiple layers of dry rhythm guitars.
They swallowed the frequency range the bass normally lives in.
3. Lars Controlled the Mix
Lars had very specific ideas:
– strong kick
– midrange-heavy snare
– guitars pushed to the front
– minimal bass
– dry as the desert
He basically dictated the production choices.
4. No One Challenged Them
Their producer, Flemming Rasmussen, wasn’t present for the final mixing stage.
James and Lars made the big decisions alone.
Recording Techniques
1. Hyper-precise editing
This is Metallica at their most structured — riffs are perfectly aligned, almost machine-like.
2. DI + Amp Blending
Guitars were blended with direct signals for clarity.
This increases dryness and reduces warmth.
3. Minimal overdubs on drums
Most drum power comes from tight editing, not layering.
4. Vocals mixed behind guitars
James’ voice is intentionally NOT dominant — unusual for Metallica.
Overall Sound Philosophy
…And Justice for All isn’t meant to sound “good” in the traditional sense.
It’s meant to sound:
– cold
– lifeless
– mechanical
– bitter
– rigid
– unforgiving
It mirrors the album’s themes of corruption, decay, and the breakdown of justice.
It’s the sound of law and society collapsing.
FAQ — …And Justice for All
1. Why is there no bass on …And Justice for All?
Because James and Lars intentionally buried the bass in the mix during production. Jason Newsted was the new member following Cliff Burton’s death, and part of his hazing was making his bass inaudible. The guitars consumed the entire low end, leaving almost no space for his tracks.
2. What genre is the album?
The album is considered progressive thrash metal — technical, complex, political, and extremely riff-dense. It’s the most structurally ambitious Metallica album ever made.
3. When was it released?
…And Justice for All was released on September 7, 1988, as Metallica’s fourth studio album.
4. Who produced the album?
Flemming Rasmussen (their longtime producer), with Metallica themselves heavily controlling the sessions. The final mix — including the removal of the bass — was guided almost entirely by James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich.
5. Who played bass on the album?
Jason Newsted performed all bass parts, but his tracks were nearly muted in the mix. Many modern remasters and fan edits attempt to restore his presence.
6. What is “Blackened” about?
It’s an apocalyptic environmental song describing the world destroyed by pollution, nuclear winter, and human negligence. It’s one of Metallica’s earliest politically charged tracks.
7. What is the meaning of the title track?
The song “…And Justice for All” attacks corruption within the legal and political system. It describes justice as a rigged game controlled by wealth and power.
8. Why is the album so dry and thin-sounding?
It was an intentional stylistic choice driven by James and Lars. They wanted a tight, claustrophobic sound that emphasized rigidity, complexity, and aggression — even at the cost of warmth.
9. What is “One” about?
“One” tells the story of a soldier who survives a battlefield explosion but loses all limbs and senses, trapped inside his own mind. It’s based on the novel Johnny Got His Gun.
10. Did “One” win a Grammy?
Yes — it earned Metallica their first Grammy in 1990 for Best Metal Performance. This award propelled them into mainstream recognition.
11. What is “Dyers Eve” about?
James Hetfield wrote it about the emotional trauma he experienced growing up in a strict Christian Science household. The song is pure catharsis — angry, fast, and deeply personal.
12. Why are the songs so long?
Because Metallica were exploring progressive structures, multiple movements, and dozens of riffs per track. They wanted to push the boundaries of thrash metal composition.
13. What influenced the album’s political themes?
Metallica were reacting to government corruption, censorship, war, and legal injustice of the 1980s. The album’s sarcasm and anger reflect distrust in institutions.
14. What is “The Frayed Ends of Sanity” about?
It deals with anxiety, paranoia, and mental collapse — someone losing control of their mind. The chaotic structure mirrors that psychological unraveling.
15. Is “To Live Is to Die” really a tribute to Cliff Burton?
Yes. The song uses riffs and ideas Cliff wrote before his death, along with a spoken passage honoring his philosophy. It’s Metallica’s most emotional instrumental.
16. Was the album hard to play live?
Extremely. The complex structures made many songs difficult to reproduce on stage, which is why some tracks (like “The Frayed Ends of Sanity”) were rarely played in full.
17. How did the album perform commercially?
It reached #6 on Billboard, went 8× Platinum in the U.S., and sold over 12 million copies worldwide. It was Metallica’s first major commercial breakthrough.
18. Why is the drum tone so strange?
Lars wanted a tight, dry, attack-heavy tone with little ambience. The result is a snare that sounds papery and kicks with an almost click-like quality.
19. Did the band ever apologize for the missing bass?
James Hetfield has expressed regret in multiple interviews, admitting the mix “wasn’t fair to Jason.” Lars, meanwhile, has defended it as “the sound for that moment.”
20. Is …And Justice for All Metallica’s most technical album?
Yes — in terms of riff count, time signatures, and structural complexity, it is their most ambitious and mathematically dense record.
21. Is there an official remaster with bass restored?
No. Even the 2018 remaster preserved the original bass-less mix. Metallica said they wanted to “respect the era.”
22. Why do fans still love this album despite the flaws?
Because the songwriting is monumental, the riffs are unmatched, and the album captures a raw emotional state no polish could recreate. Its imperfections became legend.
Conclusion — Why …And Justice for All Still Matters
…And Justice for All isn’t just an album — it’s a statement.
It’s Metallica surviving tragedy, pushing themselves past human limits, and producing the most complex thrash metal ever recorded. The cold mix, missing bass, rigid structures, and political fury weren’t accidents — they created a sonic world where corruption, trauma, and decay feel real.
It’s an album that challenges you instead of comforting you.
It demands attention.
It rewards dedication.
And more than 35 years later, it still stands as one of the most important metal records ever made — the bridge between Metallica’s underground dominance and their rise into the biggest metal band on Earth.
Leave a Reply